Q&A — Parivartana + Conjunction Order & Software Location Issues
Q&A: When two planets are in exact conjunction at the same degree, who gives the result first? The planet at the higher degree in the sign gives its result first (it is "leaving" — results given first); the planet at the lower degree gives its result later (it is "incoming" — result given last). Parivartana (exchange): if A is in B's sign and B is in A's sign, both planets have full access to each other's house resources. Software location issues: Jagannatha Hora auto-detects timezone but can be wrong for US locations — always verify against actual local time. Longitude/latitude input format.
"When two planets are in the same degree in a sign, the one at a higher degree gives its result first — it is going out. The one at a lower degree gives its result later — it is still coming in."
— P.V.R. Narasimha Rao
Q&A — Parivartana + Conjunction: Which Applies First?
A student asks: "If 2 planets are in the same house AND there is a parivartana (exchange of signs) between one of them and a third planet, which rule applies first — the conjunction exchange or the parivartana exchange?"
PVNR's honest answer: This is unresolved in the classics. No clear rule exists, and even in practice the order varies from chart to chart.
Two principles (recap):
-
Conjunction exchange: Two planets in the same house become like housemates — they take on each other's responsibilities. The basis: friendship between them. If they are friendly, exchange happens. If enemies (like Sun+Rahu), they may refuse to exchange even if in the same sign.
-
Parivartana exchange: Two planets in each other's signs — they act like they're in each other's houses. This exchange is also triggered at a particular time (a dasha/antardasha trigger), not operative from birth.
Key clarifications:
- Exchange (conjunction or parivartana) is NOT always operative from birth; it has a trigger point — a specific dasha or antardasha that activates it
- Before the trigger: each planet gives its own results
- After the trigger: the exchange kicks in and planets partially give each other's results
- Whether planets are benefic or malefic doesn't determine if they exchange — what matters is whether they are FRIENDLY toward each other
- Example: Saturn+Venus (friends) → will exchange freely
- Example: Sun+Rahu (enemies/incompatible) → will NOT exchange even if conjunct
Proximity matters for Raj Yoga (but not exchange):
- Exchange of results can happen even if planets are at the two ends of the sign (even if 29° apart)
- But Raj Yoga (a yoga of doing things together) requires CLOSE proximity — planets need to interact strongly to produce Raj Yoga results
- "Yoga means being together — they put their resources together to accomplish something. This requires close proximity."
For parivartana + conjunction combined: PVNR says experiment with known events to determine which pattern fits. No universal rule available yet.
Q&A — Software Town Names and Longitude Accuracy
If two towns have the same name in the same US state:
- JHora uses a NASA/government database; big city names are rarely duplicated
- For small towns with duplicates: ask the person for the nearest big city, then identify which one is geographically correct
- Modern solution: use Google Earth or a mapping site with the physical address to get longitude and latitude to fractions of a degree
Important reminder: Even if you get extremely accurate coordinates, if the birth time is off, the chart is inaccurate. Don't get carried away with one parameter's precision while ignoring others.
For India: JHora's database has more Indian towns than even the professional ACS Atlas. For very small villages, use the nearest big town as an approximation.